Head-to-head · Personal · Privacy · Data-Removal Services
Optery vs DeleteMe: which should you pick?
The two proof-led services head to head: measured outcomes against human escalation and readable reports. Optery wins our overall scoring (89 vs 80 out of 100), but the right choice depends on the job you need done.
Editorial disclosure: Preferred Solutions has no affiliate relationship with the products in this comparison. Both are scored on the same rubric and evidence standard as every product in the category.
Side by side
Criterion by criterion
Optery
Evidence-first choice
DeleteMe
Best for human help
Decision table
Which one fits your situation
| Your situation | Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| You want the strongest independently measured outcome | Optery | Consumer Reports measured 68% removal for Optery Ultimate against 27% for DeleteMe in the same four-month, 13-site test. |
| You want human help without a premium tier | DeleteMe | A personal privacy expert and custom requests are included at $129/yr; Optery's custom removals require the $249/yr Ultimate plan. |
| You want the widest documented broker footprint | DeleteMe | A peer-reviewed audit counted 759 unique broker domains on DeleteMe's list, 69.7% of them exclusive to DeleteMe — the strongest independent coverage evidence in this set. |
| You want to start free or nearly free | Optery | The free Exposure Report shows likely matches with screenshots and the Core plan is $39/yr; DeleteMe's scan is free but paid plans start at $129/yr. |
| You need reports someone else can follow | DeleteMe | Its sample report separates findings, in-progress removals, exposed fields, and clean sources — the most legible paper trail short of Optery's screenshots. |
Our verdict
Pick by situation, not by score alone
Choose Optery if…
People who want screenshot evidence, multiple identity variations, and human QA. Optery earns 89/100 and sets the evidence standard in this category. Its screenshots, direct profile links, human QA, and two independent outcome studies make the work easier to verify. The catch is the plan ladder: the $39 Core plan is automated and limited, while the full evidence-led experience begins at $149/year and custom removals cost $249/year.
Choose DeleteMe if…
Buyers who value human help, custom removals, and readable reports. DeleteMe earns 80/100. Its human privacy team, free scan, custom-request path, readable reports, audited security controls, and independently documented coverage make it the strongest human-help option. The red flag remains effectiveness: Consumer Reports measured only 27% removal after four months in its small 2024 test, so choose DeleteMe for service and escalation—not because the oldest name produced the strongest outcome.
The bottom line
Optery takes the overall win on our weighted rubric, but each of these wins a specific job — match the award to your situation. See the full category comparison for the rest of the field.